Skip to content
brokerbasics

Home / Guides

The law

The best interests duty, explained

Since 1 January 2021 a mortgage broker has had to act in your best interests, and to put your interests first when theirs conflict. Here is where that is written down, what ASIC says it means in practice, and where it stops.

Checked 11 November 2026. General information, not credit advice.

Where the duty is written down

The duty is in the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009, the National Credit Act for short, in Part 3-5A. It was added by the Financial Sector Reform (Hayne Royal Commission Response—Protecting Consumers (2019 Measures)) Act 2020, after the banking Royal Commission recommended it, and brokers have had to comply since 1 January 2021.

There are two obligations, and they apply side by side every time a broker gives you credit assistance:

  • The best interests duty, sections 158LA and 158LE. A mortgage broker must act in the best interests of the consumer when providing credit assistance. Section 158LA applies to a broker who holds a credit licence; 158LE to a credit representative acting under someone else’s licence.
  • The conflict priority rule, sections 158LB and 158LF. If there is a conflict between your interests and the broker’s own, or a lender’s, or anybody else’s connected to them, the broker must give priority to yours.

It is easy to look for this in the Corporations Act, because that is where the better-known best interests duty for financial advisers lives. The mortgage broker duty is a separate one, in the credit law.

Who it applies to

The Act defines a mortgage broker by what they do, not what they call themselves (section 15B). It is somebody who carries on a business of providing credit assistance for loans secured on residential property, who is not the lender on most of those loans, and who helps with loans from more than one lender. ASIC’s guidance gives the example of a mortgage manager who meets that description: they are covered too.

It covers credit regulated by the National Credit Act: loans for personal, domestic or household purposes, and loans to buy or improve residential investment property. It reaches credit cards and personal loans a broker arranges alongside a home loan. It does not cover a loan that is predominantly for a business.

It does not apply to a lender’s own staff. Somebody at a bank selling that bank’s loans is not a mortgage broker under section 15B. They are bound by other law, including the responsible lending obligations, but not by this duty. What that means in practice.

What ASIC says it expects

ASIC’s guidance on the duty is Regulatory Guide 273, Mortgage brokers: Best interests duty, issued on 24 June 2020. It is guidance, not law, but it is how the regulator says it will judge compliance. Its starting point is that the Act sets out no “safe harbour”: there is no checklist that, once ticked, means a broker has complied. What matters is the process the broker followed for you.

RG 273 describes that process in three steps:

  1. Gathering information about you: your circumstances, what you are trying to achieve, and which loan features you value.
  2. Making an individual assessment: considering a range of products that could meet your goals, and working out what is in your best interests in particular.
  3. Presenting information and recommendations: recommending in line with that assessment, explaining it so you can make an informed decision, and helping you apply for what you choose.

ASIC also expects a broker to record how they did this, including the reasons a recommended loan is in your interests, and to explain those reasons to you. That is why “why is this loan better for me than the next-best option?” is a fair question: a broker following RG 273 should already have the answer written down.

The panel has to be good enough

A broker can only recommend loans from the lenders they are accredited with, which is their panel. RG 273 says a broker should have a “reasonably representative” panel and must be satisfied it lets them act in their clients’ best interests. If a client wants a lender the broker cannot reach, ASIC expects the broker to say so. And if the broker cannot act in a client’s interests with the lenders they have, ASIC’s position is that they must not provide the credit assistance at all, and may refer the client to another broker.

Where commission fits

Brokers are still paid commission by lenders, and the duty does not change that. What it changes is how commission can bear on a recommendation. Under the conflict priority rule, where two loans would both suit you, a broker cannot choose between them on the basis of which pays more. The same Part of the Act bans conflicted remuneration, with exceptions set in the regulations: since 1 January 2021 that has meant no volume bonuses, no campaign bonuses, first-year commission calculated on the drawdown net of offset, and limits on clawbacks. How brokers are paid, with a calculator.

What it does not do

  • It does not mean the lowest rate. Cost matters: ASIC says failing to look at the lowest-cost options may suggest a broker has not met the duty, and a higher-cost recommendation needs evidence behind it. But RG 273 also says the lowest rate is not always the lowest cost, because an offset account or a fee can change the sum for a particular person.
  • It does not replace responsible lending. The lender still has to assess whether the loan is not unsuitable and whether you can repay it. The two sets of obligations are separate and both apply.
  • It does not make the decision for you. You can still choose a loan that was not the one recommended. ASIC expects a broker to make sure you understand what you chose, and to record the recommendations they made.

If you think a broker has not met it

Raise it with the broker first: every credit licensee must have an internal complaints process. If that does not resolve it, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) handles complaints about credit licensees for free, and every licensee must be a member. ASIC is the regulator and can take action on a breach, but it does not resolve individual complaints. How to find a broker’s licence and AFCA membership.

Read next