Skip to content
brokerbasics

Home / Guides

Broker or bank?

Broker vs bank: when each makes sense

Both are ordinary ways to get a home loan. They differ in how many lenders get looked at, what the person helping you owes you in law, and who pays them. Neither is the right answer for everybody, and this page does not pick one for you.

Checked 11 November 2026. General information, not credit advice.

Three things that actually differ

Most of the comparison comes down to three questions. Everything else follows from them.

  1. How many lenders’ rules get looked at. A bank’s lending staff work with that bank’s loans and that bank’s policies. A broker works with the lenders on their panel, which might be a few dozen. Lenders differ in their rates, but they differ at least as much in their rules: how they count overtime, bonuses or self-employed income, what they make of a short time in a job, which properties they will lend on.
  2. What the person helping you owes you in law. A mortgage broker has a statutory duty to act in your best interests and to put your interests first in a conflict. A bank employee selling that bank’s loans does not have that duty. Both are bound by responsible lending law. The duty, explained.
  3. Who pays them, and how. A broker is usually paid commission by whichever lender you end up with, and has to disclose it. Bank staff are paid by the bank. Neither is a fee you pay directly, in the ordinary case. How broker commission works.

Going straight to a lender

This is a normal way to get a home loan. What it involves:

  • One lender’s policy is applied. If your application fits it, the process can be quick. If part of it does not, the answer from that lender is no, and that says nothing about what another lender would have said.
  • Nobody in between. There is no third party to brief, no panel to ask about and no commission riding on which loan you pick.
  • Your history may already be there. A lender you bank with can see your income arriving and your accounts, which it can use in assessing you.
  • Some lenders only deal direct. Not every lender accepts loans from brokers. If the loan you want is from one of those, going direct is the only route to it.
  • Comparing is your job. You can compare lenders yourself. Each formal application usually means a credit check that is recorded on your credit report, so finding out a lender’s rules before you apply is cheaper than finding out by applying.

Going through a mortgage broker

Also a normal way to get a home loan, and the more common one: the industry association reported brokers wrote 81.6% of new residential home loans in the June 2026 quarter. What it involves:

  • The broker compares their panel before anything is lodged, and one application goes to the lender chosen.
  • A best interests duty is owed to you, and ASIC expects the broker to record why the loan they recommend suits you.
  • The panel is a list, not the market. It varies between brokers. Ask which lenders are on it and which ones they actually use.
  • Commission is paid on the loan you choose, and rates differ between lenders. That is the conflict the duty and the 2021 pay rules exist to manage, and why the disclosure is worth reading.
  • The broker does the paperwork and deals with the lender through to settlement. That is part of what the commission pays for.

When each tends to come up

None of these is a rule, and none of them says what you should do. They are the situations where people commonly find one route simpler than the other.

Going direct often comes up when

  • The application is straightforward: one salary, one employer, a deposit already saved, nothing unusual about the property.
  • The lender you want only deals directly with borrowers.
  • You want your accounts, offset and loan with one institution, and one relationship.
  • You are changing a loan you already have with that lender: a repricing, a top-up, or a switch between its own products.

A broker often comes up when

  • Your income is anything other than a simple salary: self-employed, casual, contract, commission, overtime, or more than one job.
  • A lender has already said no, and you want to know whether another lender’s rules would fit.
  • You want lenders compared but would rather not make the applications yourself.
  • You want someone else to manage the paperwork and the lender through to settlement.

Either way, the comparison can end at your own bank. A broker following the best interests duty should reach that answer too, if it is the one that suits you.

Questions that help either way

Whoever you talk to, it helps to ask what their pay depends on, which options they considered, and why the loan they suggest suits you rather than the next-best one. A bank’s lending staff can tell you about their own loans in detail; a broker can tell you about their panel. The full list of questions, ready to print.

Read next