Who pays a mortgage broker?
In the ordinary case, the lender. When a loan a broker arranged settles, the lender pays a commission, and it keeps paying a smaller one each month the loan stays open. You do not pay it, it is not added to your loan, and the rate you are offered is the lender’s rate either way.
The money usually goes first to an aggregator, the business most brokers lodge their loans through, which keeps a share and passes the rest to the broker business. ASIC found that on average the lender paid the aggregator 0.62% upfront and 0.18% a year in trail, and the broker business received about 0.54% and 0.14% of that.
Some brokers also charge you a fee, more often on complicated or commercial loans. That is allowed, and it has to be disclosed to you before you go ahead.
Upfront commission
A one-off payment when the loan settles, worked out as a percentage of the loan. ASIC’s review of lenders’ agreements found upfront rates were usually between 0.5% and 0.8% of the loan amount, with a few outside that band (0.375% at the lowest and 1.1% at the highest).
ASIC’s own worked example: on a $500,000 loan, a 0.62% upfront commission is $3,100.
It is calculated net of your offset
Since 1 January 2021, commission in a home loan’s first year cannot be calculated on more than the amount you have actually drawn down, less what is sitting in any offset account. Before then it often was not: when ASIC surveyed lenders, 14 of 19 worked out upfront commission on the approved limit (or required the whole loan drawn at settlement), and none of them took an offset balance off it. So on a $600,000 loan with $50,000 in an offset at 0.62%, the upfront commission is $3,410, not $3,720.
Trail commission
An ongoing payment, worked out each month as an annual percentage of what you still owe. ASIC found trail rates generally between 0.1% and 0.35% a year, and that every lender it surveyed paid it monthly and stopped when the loan was repaid. Some lenders paid a flat rate; others paid more the longer the loan had run. Ten of the lenders ASIC surveyed already took an offset balance off the trail calculation; after the first year the 2021 rules leave that to the lender, so the calculator nets the offset off every year and a real loan may not.
Because it is a share of the balance, trail shrinks as you repay. On the calculator’s starting example, a $600,000 loan, trail at 0.18% is $1,074 in the first year and $5,225 over 5 years.
Trail is the part of the arrangement that is easy to forget about. Supporters say it pays for a broker to stay available after settlement; critics, including ASIC in its 2017 review, said the standard model of upfront plus trail creates conflicts of interest. Either way, it is paid for as long as the loan is open.
What the 2021 reforms changed
The rules for how a broker can be paid changed on 1 January 2021, in response to the banking Royal Commission:
- No volume or campaign bonuses. A lender may no longer pay a broker more for writing more loans with it, or a bonus for loans written during a promotion.
- First-year commission on the drawdown, net of offset. As above.
- Clawbacks limited to two years, and the borrower must not be made to pay because of one. How a clawback works.
- A best interests duty and a rule that your interests come first when there is a conflict. The duty, explained.
The reforms did not set or cap a commission rate. Upfront and trail commission are both still allowed.
How you find out what your broker is paid
You do not have to work it out from ranges. A broker has to give you a credit guide early on, which says how they are paid in general, and a credit proposal disclosure document when they help you with a particular loan, which sets out the fees you pay and a reasonable estimate of the commission they expect to receive. Ask for both, and ask for the commission on each option you are shown, not just the one being recommended.
How old these figures are
The ranges here are from ASIC Report 516, published in March 2017, which read lenders’ agreements and loan data from 2012 to 2015. It is still the most recent market-wide figure from a regulator. Commission rates move, and an individual lender’s rate can sit outside them, so the calculator lets you move the rates wherever you like. Your broker’s disclosure is the number that applies to you.